Cognitive Defusion in Counselling
A thought can feel very convincing without being something you have to act on.
Maybe your mind keeps returning to I'm going to mess this up. Or They must be upset with me. Or I can't handle this.
Trying to argue with a thought or make it disappear doesn't always help. Sometimes it can be more useful to notice that the thought is there and change how you respond to it.
Cognitive defusion is a concept and set of exercises associated with Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT). Rather than trying to prove whether a thought is true or false, defusion can help you notice a thought as a thought—something your mind is doing in that moment.
The goal isn't to stop thinking, get rid of difficult thoughts, or convince yourself to think positively. It's to create a little more room to decide what you want to do when a thought shows up.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cognitive Defusion
-
Cognitive defusion is a way of changing how you relate to your thoughts.
Sometimes a thought can show up and immediately feel like a fact, a warning, or something you need to respond to. Defusion exercises can help you notice the thought without automatically getting pulled into it.
For example, there can be a difference between:
I'm going to fail.
and:
I'm having the thought that I'm going to fail.
The second doesn't try to prove the thought wrong. It simply notices that a thought is happening.
That can leave a little more room to decide what you want to do next.
-
Yes.
Cognitive defusion is one of the processes used in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, often called ACT.
ACT includes more than defusion. It also works with things like acceptance, awareness of the present moment, values, and taking action toward what matters to you.
A counsellor can draw on cognitive defusion exercises without using ACT as their primary approach.
-
Not quite.
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and cognitive defusion can both involve working with thoughts, but they may approach them differently.
In CBT, you might examine a thought, look at the evidence for and against it, and consider whether there's another way of looking at the situation.
With cognitive defusion, you don't necessarily need to decide whether the thought is accurate. Instead, you might notice how you're relating to it and what happens when it shows up.
There can be room for both approaches in counselling. Which is useful can depend on the thought, the situation, and what works for you.
-
No.
A thought doesn't have to be inaccurate for defusion to be useful.
You might think, I'm nervous about this conversation, and actually be nervous. Or you might think, This could go badly, when that's genuinely possible.
Defusion isn't about convincing yourself that everything will be okay. It's about noticing the thought and deciding how you want to respond, rather than assuming the thought has to make that decision for you.
-
No.
Cognitive defusion isn't about clearing your mind, thinking positively, or making certain thoughts disappear.
Thoughts can keep showing up even when we don't want them to.
Instead of putting all of the effort into stopping a thought, defusion can help you practise noticing it and choosing what you want to do next.
-
There are many different cognitive defusion exercises.
One of the simplest is changing the way you describe a thought.
Instead of:
I can't do this.
you might try:
I'm having the thought that I can't do this.
Other exercises might involve giving a familiar thought pattern a name, noticing thoughts as they come and go, repeating a word until it begins to sound more like a collection of sounds, or using imagery to picture thoughts passing by.
The particular exercise matters less than what you're practising: noticing a thought without automatically needing to argue with it, get rid of it, or follow it.
-
No.
There are plenty of thoughts worth paying attention to.
A thought might remind you of something important, point toward a real problem, help you recognize what matters to you, or give you information you want to consider.
Defusion isn't about dismissing thoughts.
It gives you another option besides automatically treating every thought as an instruction or a fact that requires an immediate response.
-
It can still be something you work with.
Defusion isn't successful only when a thought stops appearing. A familiar thought may come back many times.
The question can become less about How do I make this thought go away? and more about What happens when this thought shows up, and what do I want to do when it does?
Over time, you may find different ways of responding to a thought even if you can't control whether it appears.
-
Then it may not be the right exercise for you.
Some defusion exercises deliberately use unusual language, repetition, imagery, or humour. One person may find an exercise surprisingly useful while someone else finds the same exercise distracting, awkward, or irritating.
You don't need to force yourself to use a particular technique because it's supposed to work.
You and your counsellor can pay attention to what is actually useful for you and try something different when it isn't.
-
They overlap, but they aren't exactly the same thing.
Both can involve noticing thoughts without immediately reacting to them.
Mindfulness is broader and can involve paying attention to thoughts, emotions, physical sensations, and what's happening around you in the present moment.
Cognitive defusion focuses more specifically on changing how you relate to thoughts and language.
-
It may be worth exploring when thoughts seem to take up a lot of space or strongly influence what happens next.
Maybe you keep replaying a conversation. Maybe your mind jumps quickly to what could go wrong. Maybe a familiar thought about yourself appears whenever you try something new. Or perhaps you spend a lot of time arguing with thoughts that keep returning anyway.
That doesn't automatically mean cognitive defusion will be the right approach.
It gives you and your counsellor another way of working with thoughts when trying to eliminate, avoid, or debate them hasn't been particularly helpful.
-
It can be quite simple.
Your counsellor might help you notice a thought that keeps showing up and pay attention to what happens when you get caught up in it. You might try changing the language around the thought, saying it differently, using an image or metaphor, or experimenting with another defusion exercise.
Then you can notice what changes—and what doesn't.
The goal isn't to perform an exercise correctly. It's to find out whether relating to the thought differently gives you more room to respond in a way that works for you.
-
Cognitive defusion exercises may be useful when you're dealing with things like:
Thoughts that keep repeating
Worry about what might happen
Harsh or critical thoughts about yourself
Replaying conversations or situations
Getting caught up in what other people might be thinking
Thoughts that make it harder to try something new
Getting stuck trying to make a decision
Thoughts that seem to quickly lead to avoidance
Trying hard not to think about something
Spending a lot of time arguing with your own thoughts
You don't need to decide whether a thought is rational, irrational, positive, or negative before you can work with it.
Sometimes the starting point is simply noticing what your mind is saying and what happens next.
Find a Counsellor Who Uses Cognitive Defusion
-

Carmel Mohebati, CCC
Clinical Counsellor
Online and by phone across Canada | In-person in Victoria, BC.